Oven Repair or Replace: How to Choose the Best Option

If your oven is acting up, the first thought is usually “Can I fix it?” but the deeper question is "Is it worth it?" Instead of guessing, let’s break down the key factors that tell you when a repair will save you money and when buying a new oven is the smarter move.

Check the Age and Cost of Repairs

Age is the biggest clue. Most ovens last about 10‑15 years with normal use. If yours is under 7 years old, a repair is often a good bet because parts are still readily available and the technology isn’t outdated. Once you hit the 10‑year mark, parts become scarcer and labor costs climb.

Next, get a clear quote. Call a few local repair services (including Wells Appliance Repairs) and ask for a written estimate that includes parts, labour, and any call‑out fees. Compare that number to the price of a comparable new oven. A useful rule of thumb is: if the repair cost is more than 50 % of the price of a new unit, start looking at replacement options.

Common Problems That Might Be Worth Fixing

Not every glitch means you need a brand‑new oven. Here are the issues that often get fixed for a fraction of the cost of a new appliance:

• Heating element failure – Replacing a burnt element usually costs under £100. If the rest of the oven is in good shape, this is a quick win.
• Control board issues – A faulty board can cause random shut‑offs or temperature errors. Diagnosis is cheap, and a new board typically runs between £80‑£150.
• Thermostat or sensor problems – Sensors can drift over time, leading to uneven cooking. Swapping them out is straightforward and inexpensive.
• Door seal leaks – A cracked door gasket lets heat escape, making baking uneven. Replacement seals are cheap and easy to install.

If you’re seeing multiple failures at once – for example, a broken element plus a faulty control board – that’s a sign the oven’s overall reliability is waning. In that case, replacing might be the better long‑term choice.

Also, think about energy efficiency. Modern ovens use less electricity and heat up faster. Even if the repair cost is just under the 50 % threshold, a newer model could save you money on bills for years to come.

Finally, consider safety. A cracked wiring harness or a failing gas valve isn’t something you want to gamble on. If a repair involves any gas components, always have a qualified professional handle it – the cost of a mistake far outweighs the price of a new oven.

Bottom line: weigh age, repair quotes, and the specific fault. Small, isolated problems usually merit a repair, while multiple or high‑cost issues in an older oven point toward replacement. When in doubt, give a trusted local service like Wells Appliance Repairs a call. They’ll diagnose the problem fast, give you a transparent quote, and help you make the right call for your kitchen and your wallet.